What's not to love about ROTS? It's funny that most of the "bad" stuff associated with the movies is mostly stuff that was NOT in it rather than stuff that was. So, if with this film production GL was able to please both the fanbase and the casual moviegoer he truly was succesful. Nobody here could pull off what he did in almost 2 1/2 hours in terms of storytelling and eventual story connection. He had a story to tell, plain and simple, and most of the things some people complain about not seeing are not elements that are essential to the story telling of this particular episode. That is editing, which is far more than puting scenes in a sequential order. Iterest, flow, consistency, intensity and committment to the story are more important to a filmmaker than making a 100% pleased fan checklist approved film. That reminds me of Boba Fett plunging into the Saarlac pit. So we didn't get to see much of Tarkin. Heck, we have a whole episode 4 chock full of him. Yet the story is told in its fullness.
However as I watched ANH the other day I noticed some minor detail that bothered me little.
Obi-Wan to Luke: "I haven't been called by the name of Obi-Wan since LONG BEFORE you were born."
REALLY?....
I believe I heard the name Obi Wan a couple of times in ROTS, which was not long before Luke was born. But of course, that was the script in 1976 when they didn't even dream about making prequels. Or maybe is just a case of Alzheimer's disease showing up on an aging Obi-Wan.